With numerous conflicting narratives regarding Muhammad and his companions from various sources, it was necessary to verify which sources were more reliable.
Concerning itself mainly with secondary sources, a historiographical essay discusses the body of research, debate and discussion on a particular historical topic. If you are at a loss, here are some tips to get you started. Step 1 Settle on a topic.
If you are writing this essay for a class, you may be assigned this. Otherwise, you will have to create your own.
Make sure it is clearly defined, arguable and has substance. Step 2 Collect your secondary sources.
In general, the works should be no more than 30 years old. It is important to get as many books as you possibly can on the topic to facilitate a more detailed, varied and complete essay. Step 3 Begin to read. It will take you forever to read each and every book through, so read strategically, using the index to point you toward information that is relevant to your topic.
Step 4 Take notes. Write down what each author has to say about the topic and examine the viewpoint critically.
Keep in mind where the author has come from, the time and context they wrote in, and their approach and methods.
This will better help you understand their arguments. Step 5 Next, gather your notes and examine how each view contributes to and shapes the discussion. What or who does each author agree or disagree with and how?
How are they similar and how do they differ? Is scholarship on the subject lacking or has it run its course? Step 6 Once you have your notes, you can begin writing your paper. Your introduction should include the historical topic you are exploring. The rest of the paper will evaluate the body of work you have read in order to present a cohesive picture of opinions and debate.
Things You Will Need.If you are writing a larger paper, you can integrate your historiography over the course of the paper addressing the work of previous historians as they relate to your own analysis. The first two methods are generally more what is expected of you when you are assigned to "write a historiography.".
A historiography can be a stand-alone paper, in which case your paper examines the work completed by other historians. Alternately, a historiography can act as an introduction to a major research paper, in which you will go on to add your own analysis.
Step 4: Write your historiography One good tactic is to combine step 3 with step 4, plugging each source into the overall framework as you go and thus saving you from having to reread every source twice. Jan 30, · Historiographical essay examples Below please find several examples of historiographical essays.
What they share in common is an effort to chart changes in the questions asked by historians of a particular topic or field, or the sort of sources they consult; they also usually seek to explain why new questions have emerged (causation) and to.
A historiography is a summary of the historical writings on a particular topic - the history of eugenics in America, or the history of epidemics, for example. It sets out in broad terms the range of debate and approaches to the topic. For example: "The historiography of the decision to use the atomic bomb on Hiroshima changed over the years as new research questioned the former consensus view that the decision to drop the atomic bomb was predicated on the necessity to save American lives.".